Six middle- and high-school students sat around a table on
a Monday afternoon, watching a psychologist write three letters on a
whiteboard:
O-C-D.
“What does O.C.D. stand for?” the psychologist, Avital
Falk asked the group.
“Obsessive-compulsive disorder,” answered a timid A 12-year-old boy wearing a blue blazer and red tie.
“What makes it a disorder?” Dr. Falk asked.
“Because it’s messing up our lives,” said Sydney, a chatty
14-year-old with long red hair.
These children have O.C.D., an illness characterized by
recurrent, intrusive thoughts and repetitive behaviors, or other problems with
anxiety.
They are also participants during a novel treatment program at Weill
Cornell Medicine in NY.
Typically patients with O.C.D. see a therapist once every
week for an hour over several months, but this program consists of two-hour
group meetings 3 times every week, plus up to four additional hours of
individual therapy per week.
Some patients complete the treatment in only
fortnight.
The program, which began in 2016, is a component of a
replacement wave of concentrated, intensive therapy programs for psychiatric
disorders.
The kid Mind Institute in NY launched a two-day “boot camp” for
teens with social anxiety last year.
The Houston O.C.D. Program in Texas
operated its first weeklong treatment program for adolescents during respite
for local schools.
In Atlanta, Emory University is in its third year of a
two-week therapy program for veterans with post-traumatic stress disorder,
funded by the Wounded Warrior Project.
Similar offerings for veterans are now available at
U.C.L.A. Health in California, Rush University center in Chicago and
Massachusetts General Hospital in Boston.
The approach is gaining popularity partially due to new
research showing that for both adults and youngsters, the concentrated the approach is usually even as effective, and in some ways simpler, as treatment
that's opened up over several months.
A meta-analysis of randomized, controlled trials published last year within the journal Behaviour Research and Therapy found remission rates of 54 percent for youngsters in intensive, concentrated cognitive behavioral therapy (C.B.T.) for anxiety disorders and 57 percent for those in standard C.B.T., a difference that wasn't statistically significant.
A meta-analysis of randomized, controlled trials published last year within the journal Behaviour Research and Therapy found remission rates of 54 percent for youngsters in intensive, concentrated cognitive behavioral therapy (C.B.T.) for anxiety disorders and 57 percent for those in standard C.B.T., a difference that wasn't statistically significant.
Just 2.3 percent of patients who did the concentrated
therapy dropped out during treatment, compared with 6.5 percent for normal
C.B.T. At Emory, only 5 percent of veterans within the two-week PTSD program
left before finishing, consistent with a paper published within the fall of
2017.
Another meta-analysis (this one among both randomized,
controlled trials and studies without an impact group), published in 2015
within the Journal of Obsessive-Compulsive and Related Disorders, found that
O.C.D. patients who were treated with intensive, concentrated therapy were more
improved after treatment ended than those that received traditional weekly or
twice weekly C.B.T.
At a follow-up point of about three months, both groups
were equally improved.
The intensive treatments seem to figure best for
anxiety-related disorders.
They typically contain C.B.T., during which
patients repeatedly expose themselves to the very situations they fear.
Supporters of the approach said that while it's going to
involve an identical number of total hours as weekly therapy, relief is
quicker. Thomas H.
Ollendick, a psychology professor at Virginia Tech, who helped pioneer a one-day treatment for phobias and has studied a one-week treatment for O.C.D. said this will be crucial for people whose illnesses are preventing them from attending school or work.
Ollendick, a psychology professor at Virginia Tech, who helped pioneer a one-day treatment for phobias and has studied a one-week treatment for O.C.D. said this will be crucial for people whose illnesses are preventing them from attending school or work.
And with concentrated treatment, Dr. Ollendick said, “you
don’t have every week in between to unlearn what you learned within the session
or have additional experiences which will lead you to think, ‘Oh, I better be
afraid.’”
The concentrated format allows therapists to deliver
evidence-based treatment to more people, since it’s easier for patients who
sleep in places without access to high-quality therapy to travel for a one- of the two-week program, said Donna B.
Pincus, director of the kid and Adolescent Fear and Anxiety Treatment Program at Boston University, which runs five- to eight-day intensive treatment programs for anxiety disorder, separation mental disorder and phobias.
Pincus, director of the kid and Adolescent Fear and Anxiety Treatment Program at Boston University, which runs five- to eight-day intensive treatment programs for anxiety disorder, separation mental disorder and phobias.
Even patients who live nearby may find it easier to require
off every week of labor or plan treatment during a faculty break, instead of
affect the logistics of weekly therapy.
“People are pulled out of their everyday lives for 2 weeks
— they're not handling work and spouses and youngsters,” said Barbara O.
Rothbaum, a professor of psychiatry and behavioral sciences at the Emory
University School of drugs.
“It really may be quite a bubble for them to try to this work.”
The intensive, concentrated approach also has downsides.
The worth tag for the Houston respite program, for instance, was $2,500 for
the week.
Many programs don’t accept insurance.
Sometimes insurance companies will reimburse for less than a little portion of treatment or would require patients to first prove that less intensive therapy has failed before coverage kicks in.
Sometimes insurance companies will reimburse for less than a little portion of treatment or would require patients to first prove that less intensive therapy has failed before coverage kicks in.
Patients also got to be motivated and prepared and willing
to maneuver quickly into exposure work, noted Boston University’s, Dr. Pincus.
Some patients use concentrated therapies to kick-start
treatment or as an adjunct to longer-term therapy.
0 comments:
Post a Comment